Homemade Everything Bagels Recipe (Vegan-Friendly!)

By Callie  

A homemade everything bagel is a weekend project specifically worth doing, and it’s more approachable than most people expect. Five ingredients in the dough (flour, yeast, water, salt, and brown sugar), a 3-hour autolyse rest that requires zero attention, a water bath step that takes 4 minutes for a full batch, and a 20-minute bake. The result is a bagel that has the chewy, dense, slightly lacquered exterior and the tender, structured interior that store-bought bagels approximate but don’t quite match – because most of what makes a bagel specifically a bagel comes from the water bath step that commercial bagels often skip or abbreviate.

The two technique elements that distinguish a real bagel from a bread roll shaped like a bagel are the low-hydration dough and the boiling water bath. Low-hydration bagel dough (approximately 55% hydration compared to 65-70% for standard bread dough) produces a specifically dense, chewy crumb structure that holds up to toasting, to cream cheese application, to lox and all the accompaniments on a fully loaded bagel. The water bath sets the exterior starch into a slightly gelatinized, slightly shiny shell before the bagel goes into the oven – this pre-gelatinization is specifically what produces the characteristic bagel exterior: slightly shiny, slightly chewy, specifically crisp after toasting. Without the water bath: a bread roll shaped like a circle. With the water bath: specifically a bagel.

I made these for the first time when Emily asked why we buy bagels every week when we make so many other breads from scratch. Genuinely honest question. The answer was that bagels seemed more complicated than they are – the water bath specifically felt like a specialized technique I’d been avoiding. After the first batch: Emily ate one while it was still warm from the oven, ate a second one after toasting it, and then asked how many were going into the freezer. My husband said they were “genuinely good bagels” – which for someone who grew up eating specifically good New York bagels is a measured but meaningful assessment. For the companion that uses these fresh homemade bagels as the base for a full brunch spread, the Fully Loaded Bagel Bar is the occasion-appropriate next step after a successful bagel batch.

Why You Will Love These Homemade Everything Bagels

• The 3-hour autolyse rest develops gluten structure passively – no extended kneading required. Autolyse (from the French for “self-digestion”) is the technique of mixing flour and water together and allowing the mixture to rest before adding remaining ingredients or beginning to knead. During the rest, the flour’s proteins (glutenin and gliadin) hydrate and begin forming the gluten networks that produce bread’s structure, without any mechanical effort. After a 3-hour autolyse: the dough has developed significantly more gluten than the same dough mixed and immediately kneaded. When the remaining flour, salt, and sugar are added: the kneading time drops from 15-20 minutes (without autolyse) to 5-7 minutes (with autolyse). The autolyse also improves the dough’s extensibility – it stretches more easily during shaping without tearing. For a low-hydration, stiff bagel dough: this is specifically the technique that makes the kneading manageable.
• The boiling water bath with brown sugar is specifically what gives homemade bagels their characteristic exterior – and it takes 4 minutes for 8 bagels. Two things happen in the water bath. First: the heat gelatinizes the surface starch of the bagel into a slightly glossy, slightly firm shell. This shell specifically prevents the bagel from expanding dramatically in the oven heat (the gelatinized surface is less elastic than uncooked dough) – which is why bagels have a denser, tighter crumb than buns baked without a water bath. Second: the brown sugar in the water adds a small amount of sugar to the bagel’s exterior, which promotes the specific golden-brown Maillard browning during baking. The 1 minute per side timing is specifically calibrated: longer boiling produces an overly chewy, dense exterior; shorter boiling produces insufficient gelatinization and the bagel expands like a bread roll in the oven.
• The everything bagel seasoning pressed onto the wet bagel surface immediately after the water bath is the specific application method that makes the seasoning adhere permanently through baking. Everything bagel seasoning (sesame seeds, poppy seeds, onion flakes, flaked salt) pressed onto a dry bagel surface before baking will fall off during the oven‘s heat. Pressed onto a wet, just-boiled bagel surface: the starch on the wet exterior acts as a natural adhesive that bonds the seasoning to the surface as it dries in the oven. The moist bagel surface holds the seeds, the heat sets them, and the result is a bagel where the seasoning remains intact through toasting. The 5-second window after the water bath – while the surface is wet – is specifically when to apply the seasoning.
• This dough uses only weight measurements because bagel dough’s low hydration makes volume measurement inconsistency specifically impactful. A scooped cup of flour (approximately 150-160g) vs a spooned-and-leveled cup (approximately 125-130g) is a 15-20% variation. In a 65% hydration bread dough: this variation produces a slightly different texture but still functional bread. In a 55% hydration bagel dough: the same variation produces a dough that is either too dry and crumbly or too wet and soft to achieve the chewy, dense bagel structure. Weight measurements eliminate this source of variation. The recipe provides volume approximations as reference, but investing 30 seconds in a kitchen scale produces significantly more consistent results.
• The dough can be shaped and refrigerated overnight for a next-morning bake – the cold retard produces more complex flavor without any extra active effort. After shaping the bagels: place on a parchment-lined tray, cover with plastic wrap, and refrigerate overnight (8-12 hours) rather than proceeding immediately to the water bath. The cold slows the yeast activity, allowing the dough to develop more complex flavors from the extended fermentation – the same principle as no-knead bread’s long cold rise and sourdough bread’s cold retard. The next morning: remove from the refrigerator 30 minutes before boiling (to take the chill off), then proceed with the water bath and bake. The cold-retard bagels have more depth of flavor and a slightly more complex, slightly less yeasty aroma than same-day bagels.

Everything Bagel Ingredients

Bagel Dough (Makes 8 Bagels)

• 4g (about 1.5 teaspoons) active dry yeast
• 250g (about 1 cup) warm water – 100-110 degrees F; too hot kills yeast, too cold slows activation
• 450g (about 3.5 cups, spooned and leveled) all-purpose flour, divided – 225g for the autolyse, 225g added after
• 4g (about 3/4 teaspoon) fine salt
• 30g (about 2 tablespoons) brown sugar, divided – 20g in the dough, 10g in the water bath

Everything Bagel Topping

• 4g (1/2 tablespoon) white sesame seeds
• 4g (1/2 tablespoon) black sesame seeds
• 4g (1/2 tablespoon) poppy seeds
• 4g (1/2 tablespoon) dried onion flakes
• 2g (1/4 teaspoon) flaked salt (Maldon or similar)

Ingredient Notes And Substitutions

All-purpose vs bread flour: All-purpose flour (approximately 10-12% protein) produces a good bagel with adequate chew. Bread flour (12-14% protein) produces a specifically chewier, more structurally dense bagel – the higher protein content develops a stronger gluten network that resists the oven‘s heat more and produces the firmer, chewier crumb that authentic bagels have. For the most authentic bagel texture: use bread flour. For a slightly softer result (appropriate if the bagels will be eaten fresh without extensive toasting): all-purpose flour produces a good result.

Active dry vs instant yeast: Active dry yeast (used in this recipe) requires dissolution in warm water before use and a 5-10 minute bloom period to confirm viability. Instant yeast can be added directly to the dry ingredients without dissolving first. To substitute instant yeast: use 3g (slightly less than 1 teaspoon) of instant yeast instead of the 4g of active dry, and add it directly to the flour rather than dissolving in water first. Both produce equivalent results; the process differs slightly.

The brown sugar in the water bath: The brown sugar contributes to the bagel’s golden-brown color during baking (the Maillard reaction of the sugar on the bagel’s exterior) and adds a very slight sweetness to the exterior. Some traditional recipes use baking soda or lye (sodium hydroxide) in the water bath instead of or alongside sugar – the alkaline water bath produces the specifically dark, specific “pretzel bagel” exterior. For a standard bagel exterior without the pretzel quality: brown sugar is the correct choice.

Callie’s Kitchen Note: Emily’s question about why we buy bagels when we make other breads from scratch is the question that specifically needed to be answered by making them. My previous avoidance was based on the water bath feeling like a technical step I’d need to be careful about – and it is a step that requires attention, but it’s also one of the most satisfying steps in any bread recipe. Watching the bagels float in the boiling water, flipping them at exactly 1 minute, and then seeing the exterior change to a slightly glossy, specifically bagel-looking surface as they come out of the water: this is specifically the moment when the project becomes real. Before the water bath, they look like bread rolls with holes. After it, they look like bagels. The transformation happens in the pot.

How To Make Everything Bagels

1- The Autolyse (3 Hours Passive)

In a large bowl, combine the yeast with the 250g of warm water (100-110 degrees F). Stir briefly and allow to sit for 5 minutes – the water should become slightly foamy and smell specifically of active yeast. If there’s no activity after 5 minutes: the yeast is old or the water was too hot or too cold. Discard and start with fresh yeast and properly-tempered water.

Add 225g of the flour (half the total) to the yeast-water mixture. Stir with a wooden spoon or spatula until fully incorporated – no dry flour should remain. The mixture will be thick and paste-like rather than a dough. Cover the bowl tightly with plastic wrap. Allow to rest at room temperature for 3 hours. During this rest: the gluten develops naturally (autolyse), the yeast begins its work, and the flour fully hydrates. The mixture will look slightly puffier at 3 hours than at the start.

Why The Autolyse Specifically Matters For Low-Hydration Bagel Dough

Standard bread dough (65-70% hydration) is moist enough that the flour hydrates relatively quickly and gluten develops with moderate kneading. Bagel dough (approximately 55% hydration) is significantly stiffer – the lower water content means the flour hydrates more slowly and the gluten is harder to develop through kneading alone. Without autolyse: 15-20 minutes of vigorous kneading would be needed to develop adequate gluten, and the resulting dough is often over-worked before it reaches the ideal texture. With autolyse: the flour has pre-hydrated and the gluten has begun developing; the subsequent 5-7 minutes of kneading brings the structure to completion without over-working. The autolyse makes the difference between a kneading process that feels like a workout and one that feels manageable.

2- Add Remaining Ingredients And Knead

After the 3-hour autolyse: add the remaining 225g of flour, the 4g of salt, and 20g of brown sugar to the bowl. Mix with a spatula until roughly incorporated – the dough will seem too dry at first as the stiff post-autolyse mixture absorbs the additional flour. Turn the dough onto a clean surface and knead by hand for 5-7 minutes. The correct bagel dough is specifically stiff and should not be sticky: it should feel significantly firmer than standard bread dough but should not crumble or tear. It should hold together as a cohesive mass that gradually becomes smoother with kneading. At 5-7 minutes: the dough should be smooth, uniform in color, and spring back slowly (not immediately) when pressed with a finger.

Return the dough to the bowl. Cover and allow to rest for 15 minutes. This brief rest relaxes the gluten after the kneading and makes the dough more extensible for shaping.

3- Shape The Bagels

Divide the rested dough into 8 equal pieces – use a kitchen scale for this (approximately 115-120g per piece for consistent bagels). Shape each piece into a smooth ball by cupping the hand over the dough piece on the work surface and rotating it in a circular motion while pressing lightly downward – this motion tightens the surface tension and produces a smooth, round ball.

To form the bagel hole: press your index finger through the center of each dough ball to create an initial hole. Then stretch the hole gently by hooking both index fingers through it and pulling outward until the hole is approximately 1.5-2 inches in diameter. The hole will close slightly during the rest and the bake – a hole that looks slightly too large now will look correct in the finished bagel. Place the shaped bagels on a parchment-lined baking sheet. Cover with plastic wrap and allow to rest for 20 minutes.

Callie’s Kitchen Note: The bagel hole size is specifically the variable that I misjudged on my first batch. I made the holes too small (approximately 1 inch diameter) because the dough resisted a larger opening and I didn’t push it. By the time the bagels had rested 20 minutes, proofed slightly, gone through the water bath, and baked: the holes had closed to almost nothing. The finished bagels looked more like oval rolls with a dimple than like bagels. The 1.5-2 inch hole instruction exists for exactly this reason: the dough closes during every subsequent step, so you need to start with a larger hole than looks right at the shaping stage. Second batch: 2-inch holes. Result: properly bagel-shaped bagels with an actual hole you can see through. The stretch is worth doing properly even when the dough resists.

4- The Water Bath

Fill a large pot (4-quart or larger) halfway with water. Add the remaining 10g of brown sugar. Bring to a full rolling boil over high heat. Reduce to a steady boil – not a gentle simmer, but not so vigorous that the boiling water would jostle the bagels roughly.

Drop the bagels in carefully, 3-4 at a time depending on the pot size. The bagels should float immediately or within a few seconds – floating indicates the dough has adequate air from the fermentation and will produce a light interior. A bagel that sinks and stays sunk indicates under-proofing. Boil for exactly 1 minute per side – use a timer. At the 1-minute mark: flip each bagel gently with a slotted spoon or spider strainer. Boil for 1 more minute on the second side. Remove from the water and place on the parchment-lined baking sheet (the same sheet or a fresh one).

Immediately press the top of each wet bagel firmly into the everything bagel seasoning mixture while the surface is still wet. The wet surface is specifically the adhesive – work within 30-60 seconds of the bagel coming out of the water for maximum seasoning adhesion. Press firmly enough that the seeds are embedded slightly into the surface rather than just sitting on it.

Why Exactly 1 Minute Per Side (Not More)

The boiling water bath does three things to the bagel surface: gelatinizes the outer starch layer, sets the exterior shape, and slightly tightens the crust. At 1 minute per side: the gelatinization is sufficient to produce the characteristic exterior without over-setting the crust (which would produce an exterior so firm that it cracks during the oven‘s heat rather than expanding slightly with the interior). At 2 minutes per side: the exterior is over-set and the finished bagel has a very tough, overly chewy exterior that is too dense. At 30 seconds per side: insufficient gelatinization and the bagel expands like a bread roll in the oven. One minute per side is specifically the calibrated time for this bagel dough’s hydration level.

Callie’s Kitchen Note: My husband’s “genuinely good bagels” assessment after the first batch is the one I hold to. He is specifically someone who grew up in a context where good bagels were available and has strong opinions about what a bagel should be – the specific chew, the specific exterior, the specific relationship between the crust and the interior. “Genuinely good” from this particular person is not a mild endorsement. The water bath is what he credited specifically: “they have the right exterior.” The everything seasoning staying intact through toasting (rather than falling off as it does with some brands of store-bought everything bagels) was the second quality he noticed. Both qualities come from the water bath step – the gelatinized exterior holds the seasoning; the same exterior produces the right chew.

5- Bake

Preheat the oven to 450 degrees F. Place the seasoned, water-bath-finished bagels on the parchment-lined baking sheet, seasoning-side-up. Bake on the middle rack for 20 minutes until deeply golden brown. The 450-degree F temperature is specifically needed: lower temperatures produce pale bagels without the specific caramelization of the everything seasoning; higher temperatures risk burning the seeds before the interior is fully baked.

Transfer to a wire rack immediately after baking. Allow to cool for at least 15 minutes before slicing – the interior structure continues to set during the cooling period and slicing immediately produces a gummy, under-structured crumb. The bagels are specifically best at room temperature after full cooling for clean slicing, and then toasted for eating.

Common Mistakes To Avoid

Skipping The Water Bath

The most commonly skipped step produces the most clearly inferior result. Without the water bath: the bagels bake as very dense bread rolls with a hole – no specific chew, no specific exterior, no real bagel character. The water bath is specifically what makes a bagel a bagel. It takes 4 minutes for 8 bagels. Do it.

Making The Hole Too Small

Already addressed: make the holes 1.5-2 inches. They close during resting, water bath, and baking. Start larger than looks right. The final bagel hole should be clearly visible in the finished product; a hole that looks too large at shaping looks correct after baking.

Boiling Too Long

More than 1 minute per side produces an exterior that is too set and too thick. The over-set bagel has a crust that resists the oven‘s heat and produces a very tough, dense exterior that is specifically too chewy in an unpleasant way. 1 minute per side. Timer. Every time.

Not Pressing The Seasoning Firmly

Lightly sprinkled seasoning on the wet bagel surface falls off during baking. Press firmly – the seeds should be slightly embedded in the surface, not just resting on it. Immediately after the water bath is the window. By the time the bagels have cooled to room temperature, the surface is no longer wet enough for good adhesion.

Volume-Measuring The Flour

Already addressed: for low-hydration bagel dough, flour measurement inconsistency produces specifically impactful texture variation. Use a kitchen scale. 450g of flour is exactly 450g on a scale; it might be anywhere from 380g to 530g by volume depending on how the cup was filled.

Callie’s Kitchen Note: The freezer strategy for bagels is specifically the one that makes the project most worth doing. After the first batch: eat 2-3 fresh and freeze the remaining 5-6 individually wrapped in plastic and then in a freezer bag. Frozen homemade bagels toast from frozen in a toaster perfectly, emerging crispy on the exterior and soft on the interior in the same way that they do fresh. The store-bought bagel alternative for weekday mornings: reasonable. The homemade-and-frozen alternative: specifically better, and no incremental morning effort. Making a double batch (16 bagels) on a weekend and freezing 12 of them provides approximately 3-4 weeks of better-than-store-bought morning bagels from one baking session.

Storage And Reheating

Room temperature: In an airtight container for up to 5 days. The bagel’s dense, low-hydration crumb resists staleness better than higher-hydration breads. Day-3 bagels toasted are specifically good; day-5 bagels are best reserved for toasting.

Freezer: Wrap each bagel individually in plastic wrap, then place in a sealed freezer bag. Freeze for up to 3 months. Toast from frozen on the bagel setting (or defrost setting) in a standard toaster – no thawing needed. The frozen-then-toasted bagel is specifically as good as the fresh-then-toasted bagel. This is specifically the most practical storage approach for a full batch.

Slicing before freezing: Slice the bagels before freezing if you consistently toast individual halves – the frozen sliced bagel goes directly into the toaster without any additional cutting effort. This is the 5-second time-saving step that makes the frozen batch even more useful on weekday mornings.

Everything Bagel Variations

Plain Bagels

Omit the everything seasoning. After the water bath: brush the top surface of each wet bagel with a thin layer of beaten egg (egg wash). The egg wash produces a specifically golden, slightly shiny, specifically smooth-surfaced plain bagel. No seasoning required. This is the base for cream cheese, lox and everything accompaniments from the fully loaded bagel bar, or for any topping where the everything seasoning would compete.

Sesame Bagels

Replace the everything bagel seasoning blend with 2 tablespoons of toasted white sesame seeds only. The sesame bagel is specifically the simplest, most classic flavored bagel – the toasted sesame’s nutty character against the bagel’s slightly sweet, yeasty interior is a combination that doesn’t need any additional components. Press the sesame seeds firmly into the wet surface in the same way as the everything blend.

Cinnamon Raisin Bagels

After the autolyse and before the second-flour addition: fold in 100g of plump raisins (soak briefly in warm water if they’re dry and firm) and 2 teaspoons of ground cinnamon. The cinnamon-raisin version skips the water bath seasoning entirely (no everything blend). The baked bagel has swirls of cinnamon and plump raisins distributed through the crumb. Toast and top with plain cream cheese or honey-sweetened cream cheese. This is Emily’s specifically preferred bagel direction – she requests the cinnamon raisin version every time we make bagels.

Overnight Cold-Retard Bagels (Best Flavor Version)

After shaping: place on parchment-lined trays, cover with plastic wrap, and refrigerate for 8-16 hours instead of proceeding immediately to the water bath. The cold slows fermentation and produces more complex flavor from the extended time. Next morning: remove from the refrigerator 30 minutes before boiling. Proceed with the water bath and bake as directed. The overnight-retard bagels have a more developed, slightly more complex, slightly less yeasty flavor than same-day bagels – the difference is small but specifically noticeable to anyone paying attention.

Serving Suggestions

The Classic Everything Bagel Treatment

Toasted everything bagel, full-fat cream cheese spread generously on both cut surfaces, thinly sliced smoked salmon (lox), a few capers, thin-sliced red onion, and fresh dill. This is specifically the combination that makes an everything bagel the point of the meal rather than a vehicle for toppings. The everything seasoning’s salt, sesame, and onion against the cream cheese’s richness, the lox’s smokiness, and the caper’s brine is specifically one of the most complete flavor combinations available in the breakfast-and-brunch category.

As Part Of A Bagel Bar

A full batch of homemade bagels as the centerpiece of the Fully Loaded Bagel Bar is specifically the brunch setup that earns the most consistently impressed responses. Homemade bagels – rather than store-bought – communicate that the occasion was specifically worth the effort. Set out the sliced bagels (plain, everything, and sesame if you made multiple varieties) alongside cream cheese, lox, avocado, cucumber slices, tomato, capers, and red onion. The assembly is self-directed; the bagels themselves are the specific element that elevates the whole setup.

Everything Bagels FAQ

Recipes You May Like

If these homemade everything bagels have you building a collection of from-scratch baked goods that specifically reward the weekend project investment with results noticeably better than their store-bought equivalents, here are three more from the blog in the same spirit.

Fully Loaded Bagel Bar – The brunch-occasion companion that uses these homemade bagels as the centerpiece of a complete self-serve spread. Where this recipe produces the bagels, the bagel bar post provides the complete toppings list, the setup guide, and the occasion-specific guidance for serving the bagels to a group. If the bagel batch is made for a gathering: the bagel bar post is the companion reference for what comes next.

Perfect Lox Bagel – The single-serving companion that takes these homemade everything bagels and builds the specific lox-cream cheese-caper combination into a fully composed recipe with component proportions and assembly guidance. Where this recipe produces the bagels, the lox bagel recipe provides the most classic, most specifically complementary topping treatment. Together they’re the complete from-scratch to fully-assembled bagel morning.

Honey Butter Biscuits – The from-scratch baked-bread companion for the weekend morning when the bagel project should give way to a faster, simpler alternative. Where the bagels require the 3-hour autolyse and the water bath for a total active time of about 90 minutes, the honey butter biscuits are ready in 30 minutes with no water bath, no long rest, and no specialized technique. Both are from-scratch, specifically worth-making-homemade morning breads; the effort level and the result are completely different.

Conclusion

These everything bagels have the specific chew, the specific exterior, and the specific everything-seasoning adhesion that my husband credited specifically to the water bath step – and he’s the one who grew up knowing what a specifically good bagel should be. Emily ate two the day they were made and immediately asked about the freezer strategy. The cinnamon-raisin variation is now the specifically requested variation every time.

Make the holes larger than looks right. Time the water bath to exactly 1 minute per side. Press the seasoning firmly into the wet surface immediately after boiling. Freeze what you don’t eat the first day. This is the complete practical guidance for a specifically successful bagel batch.

Tell me in the comments whether you tried the cold-retard overnight version or the cinnamon raisin direction, and whether the holes looked too large before baking and then looked exactly right after. Save this to Pinterest for your next weekend baking project or any morning that calls for a specifically real bagel – and happy baking!

Happy baking! – Callie

Print